|
Hair Mineral Analysis (HMA)
Hair mineral analysis has been used in forensics for
decades. Today, hair analysis is gaining widespread
recognition as an analytical tool for receiving
information about mineral patterns and drug abuse. Hair
analysis is a valid analytical technique that provides
important answers to puzzling historical questions,
including Beethoven's habits. Nearly 170 years ago, an
admirer (grieving the death of Ludwig van Beethoven
snipped a lock of the great composer's hair for a
keepsake and kept it in a locket. It is this strand of
hair that is expected to provide key answers. Did the
deaf composer use drugs? Was he suffering from syphilis?
Did he die of arsenic poisoning or was his health
affected by mineral deficiencies? Today's sophisticated
analytical methods can provide these and other answers,
and explanations are often unexpectedly simple. For
instance, during Beethoven's time, mercurial drugs were
used to treat syphilis and arsenic was used to kill
rodents. In minute doses, arsenic was deliberately taken
to increase virility and physical strength. Other toxins
such as lead were ingested by drinking lead-containing
water, causing, a host of neurological and behavioral
problems such as Beethoven's feared moodiness and
ill-tempered conduct. The 582 strands of hair recently
auctioned off at Sotheby's are expected to provide
important information regarding Beethoven's biochemical
makeup and its link to behavior.
Researchers William Walsh and Ronald Isaacson have
been studying the relationship between body chemistry and
behavior for decades. They have published an Impressive
amount of data, including the relations between toxic
elements and hyperactivity. They recognized that heavy
metal exposure is higher in people prone to violent
behavior and that a specific pattern of toxic exposure
and mineral deficiencies is seen among death-row inmates.
The researchers also noticed what they considered a
"genius pattern," characterized by
extraordinarily high levels of copper and sodium but low
zinc levels in hair. Individuals with this type of hair
mineral pattern are often highly intelligent and a bit
eccentric, Walsh said. The scientists documented that
hair mineral analysis is a valid test of body mineral
concentration when used appropriately. "Hair is a
dairy of what is going on in your body," Isaacson
said. After decades of studying chemicals in hair an
associating mineral patterns with behavior, the
researchers opened the HRI Pfeiffer Treatment Center
seven years ago. It aims at treating biochemical
problems, and a strand of hair often reveals the cause of
psychiatric ailments that did not respond to other more
conventional treatment.
Hair analysis has been utilized for decades, and one
of the principal factors in hair analysis is the
accessibility of hair to the external environment.
Contamination can occur from air, water, perspiration,
shampoos, dyes and other hair preparations, however,
washing techniques utilized by laboratories alleviate
these problems. Hair analysis is a ideal complement to
serum and urine as a diagnostic tool. Hair is collected
without trauma, an important point when it comes to the
toxic screening of children or the frail. I many cases
when mineral deficiencies have been noted, the
individuals inadequate mineral status may not be solely
due to a mineral deficient diet, but also be compounded
by digestive problems that cause inadequate mineral
absorption.
A review of over 1400 articles indicate that hair is
the prime tissue to be utilized when analyzing for heavy
metal and other trace mineral concentrations. Most
notable results have been obtained on heavy metal
pollutants such as lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury.
Scientists in the United States, Canada, Germany, Japan
and Sweden have all shown that elemental concentrations
in hair provide a relatively permanent record of exposure
an that there is good correlation between concentrations
in human hair and certain organs.
Chattopadyay of Dalhousie University reported during
the Second Human Hair Symposium in Atlanta, Georgia, that
concentrations of lead in hair were lowest in rural
population groups, higher in urban groups and highest in
individuals who live close to lead smelters.
Trace Minerals International, Inc. of Boulder,
Colorado compared the toxic content of hair in American,
German and Mexican children and found that concentrations
were highest in Mexican children, lower in American and
lowest in German children.
Petering and a coworker at the University of
Cincinnati College of Medicine have fed heavy metals to
animals in measured quantities and monitored hair
concentrations in an effort to correlate exposure with
concentration.
Harry Shwachman of the Children's Hospital Medical
Center in Boston along with Kopito of the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology have shown that children with
cystic fibrosis have as much as five times the normal
concentration of sodium in their hair, but only about ten
percent of the normal concentrations of tightly-bound
calcium.
Shwachman and Kopito have also found low
concentrations of sodium and potassium in the hair of
patients with celiac disease ( disorder in the digestion
and utilization of fat) and that there is generally three
to four times as much sodium and potassium in the hair of
healthy individuals. This is in spite of the fact that
the analysis of sodium and potassium in hair is not
considered one of the stronger points of hair analysis,
due to instrumentation limitations and difficulties with
sample preparation.
Shwachman and Kopito also demonstrated that hair from
victims of phenylketonuria (PKU) contains below-normal
concentrations of magnesium and calcium; and that hair
from victims of kwashiorkor, a severe protein-calorie
malnutrition disease, has markedly increased
concentrations of zinc.
Prasad of Wayne State University has shown that
marginal zinc-deficiencies in the diet can be identified
by below normal hair zinc concentrations.
Hambidge of the University of Colorado Medical Center
has confirmed this work and suggested that the problem
may exist because diets of people with low-income
generally provide little zinc. Hambidge has tested
children in Denver's Head Start Program and found that
both their hair and blood serum contain significantly
lower concentrations of zinc than specimens from children
of middle-income families. The researcher picked six
children with the lowest hair zinc concentrations for
further testing and found that taste perception was
impaired in five. Zinc supplementation restored taste
perception and increased zinc concentrations in both
blood and hair.
Both Hambidge and Walter Mertz of the U.S. Department
of Agriculture in Beltsville, Maryland, have individually
demonstrated the below-normal hair concentrations of
chromium in victims of juvenile onset diabetes.
Sheard and Carter of the Clinical Chemistry Division
of the Center for Disease Control collected data from
over 21,000 individuals and developed a standardization
technique for measuring chromium in hair.
Gordus of the University of Michigan reported that the
hair of students with high academic marks contained
substantially more copper and less iodine, lead and
cadmium than the hair of students with low marks.
Robert Pihl and colleagues of McGill University in
Montreal, Canada, report that based on hair mineral
results, they can distinguish with 98% accuracy normal
children and those with learning disabilities.
Barlow of the University of Aston in Birmingham,
England, and Kapel of the University of Leeds. have
observed a relationship between trace element profiles in
hair and four different abnormalities. Hair mineral
evaluations of three sets of identical twins revealed
similar patterns even when one of the siblings lived in a
different environment, suggesting that the metabolic
pathways of minerals and trace elements are as similar as
has been found with other diagnostic procedures.
Brain and hair tissues of Alzheimer patients have been
found to contain substantially-elevated aluminum
concentrations and researchers at the National Institute
of Health in Bethseda, Maryland, and at the Elizabeth
Hospitals in Washington, D.C. noticed an improvement in
symptoms after hair aluminum decreased.
Elemental concentrations in organs are not identical,
but certain elements are more densely concentrated in
specific organs a better understanding of the biochemical
pathway and pathophysiology of elements improves the
diagnostic and therapeutic a limitations of trace element
analysis. Hair mineral analysis evaluates tissue storage
and is in many cases the best choice when chronic
exposures and deficiencies are suspected. As was stated
by M. Laker, "HMA is an excellent, simple, and
accurate test to establish mineral and trace element
concentrations. Since the structure of hair remains
unchanged, the minerals and trace elements are fixed,
whether a sample is tested now or in a few years time.
The levels are not subject to change." Testing Method
Sampling hair is a simple procedure, but test results
greatly depend on using the correct procedure. Coloring,
bleaching and perming hair permanently alters the
structure and negatively influences the analysis, causing
falsely-elevated test results. For example, black hair
coloring agents may contain manganese, lead and or other
elements, while red dyes may result in elevated copper or
iron levels. Bleaching agents drastically change the hair
shaft and cause falsely elevated calcium and magnesium
results. Generally, a report that shows overall high
levels is not a reflection of toxicity, but indicates
chemical treatment of hair. Certain shampoos, colors, and
conditioners contain relatively large amounts of certain
trace elements which penetrate the hair and cannot be
removed by a laboratory's washing procedure. Some
laboratories have choosen not to wash hair samples prior
to analysis, a highly- questionable practice that leads
to falsely-elevated results. Clinicians interested in
hair analysis must investigate laboratories and ask
pertinent information about sample preparation. It is
only logical that test results of unwashed hair exposed
to sweat would provide falsely elevated sodium
results.
Note: If hair has been subjected to multiple
treatment (bleaching, coloring, perming) and the patient
is not willing to wait until sufficient untreated new
growth is available, it is best to use pubic hair or
nails as a sample material.
Procedures to follow:
1. Hair does not require washing before collection
since each sample will be washed meticulously at the
laboratory with deionized soap. Surface residues, such as
spray, conditioner, and dust are removed during this
process.
2. To cut a sample, use a hair dresser's shaving blade
when collecting very short hair. Use normal scissors for
hair of 5 cm (2 inches) or longer.
3. Pin hair up at the back of the head.
4. Carefully cut several strands of hair. Cut narrow
strands to avoid visible gaps.
5. Cut off ends if hair is very long; only keep strand
at a length of up to 10 cm (about 6 inches) for
analysis.
6. Repeat procedure higher up, until enough hair has
been obtained.
7. Write all patient information and needed details on
sample envelope.
How to collect Beard and Pubic Hair:
Both facial and pubic hair should be cut as close to
the skin as possible. Pubic hair from female patients
should be collected from the upper part of the pubic hair
line. Axillary hair is unsuitable for analysis.
Samples for Re-testing or Control:
It is advisable that the sample be collected from the
approximately the same area. For example, if the sample
has been collected from the nape for the first analysis,
it is advisable to collect again from the nape.
Laboratory Preparation:
Any sample that reaches the laboratory is first
numbered and recorded. After that, the hair sample is
washed in a special solution and rinsed several times
with deionized water. After the sample has been dried, it
is weighed and dissolved in nitric acid. The solution
obtained is then diluted with de-ionized water and tested
with control solutions by atomic emission
spectrophotometry (ICPAE) or mass spectrometry (MS). The
emission occurs at approximately 10,000 degrees Celsius,
and the accuracy of the analysis is monitored after five
to ten tests by comparing test results of known standard
solutions. Test results are immediately entered and
analyzed by computer, and all reports are checked and
approved by competent personnel. Nail Mineral Analysis (NMA)
Nail analysis has been used in forensics for the
evaluation of severe arsenic poisoning when hair loss
prohibited hair mineral analysis. Nail analysis is also
used when untreated hair is not available in sufficient
quantity. Finger or toenails may be used as a testing
material. but nails must be free of varnish or polish. A
minimum of 200 mg of nails Is needed for analysis.
Reference Values
1. Definition of Normal
In medicine. the definition "normal" has
several meanings. It used to distinguish a
"normal" or healthy person from the abnormal or
unhealthy individual, and in this context, we refer to
"normal" iron levels as values that reflect
good health, in fact "normal" iron
concentrations can be found in the presence of disease.
In the absence of disease or disease symptoms, a person
is medically and legally considered normal or healthy
however, a person without symptoms of disease does not
necessarily enjoy even optimal health. In the laboratory,
"normal" is used to describe a set of
laboratory results that is based on statistics. For many
analytes such as serum iron or aluminum, whole blood lead
or urine mercury, reference levels have been established
by the Center for Disease Control (CDC). For other
analytes less known in conventional medicine, including
the important blood chromium or urine nickel, reference
values have not been standardized. This applies for most
elemental reference ranges in hair, with arsenic being
one exception. In some cases, instrument sensitivity and
detection limits dictate that in spite of existing
reference ranges, a new set of values needs to be
established. For instance, while ICP-MS provides
detection limits in the PPB range traditional ICP-AES
measurement of blood lead concentrations are difficult
due to instrumentation limitations. However, the
experienced analytical chemist can statistically and
mathematically correct some of these problems by
carefully evaluating the known concentrations of standard
solutions. Thus, the establishment of a specific set of
reference values that is based on existing laboratory
conditions and variables provides a valid rationale for
establishing "laboratory-specific" reference
values. While the "normal" range of such
"laboratory-specific" reference value deviates
from official or otherwise used "normal"
ranges, analytical data that is outside that range
reflects abnormal conditions
When no reference values are officially available or
recommended by the CDC or other government agencies, the
laboratory has the responsibility to establish reference
ranges. Since 1994, All laboratories engaged in testing
human samples have to provide licensing inspectors with
sufficient statistical data that evidences the
statistical and mathematical basis which led to the
establishment of a specific set of reference values, The
only difference is that 'established' reference ranges
have demonstrated to define "normal" for a
longer period of time, and more clinical data is
available to support them.
2. Statistical Basis:
For the establishment of reference ranges, a Gaussian
distribution is generally used, although additional
statistical and mathematical measurements are taken into
account.
3. Detection Limits
The detection limit is defined as the concentration of
an element or compound that produces an instrumental
signal that is acceptably greater in intensity than the
instrumental noise (or background) level. The instruments
used at TNU are the inductively-coupled plasma mass
spectrometer (ICP-MS) and the inductively-coupled plasma
atomic emission spectrophotometer (ICP-AES). The ICP-MS
is a state-of-the-art instrument designed to provide
quantitative measurements in the parts-per-trillion
range. The ICP-AES does not provide such low detection
limits, but is more than sufficient for many applications
and better suitable to test elements that are present in
higher concentrations.
Bibliography:
Blaurock-Busch E.; Mineralstoffe und Spurenelemente
und deren Bedeutung in der Haar Mineralstoff Analvtik.
Biol Arb und Forschkr, 1984.
Blaurock-Busch E.; Confirming the Biochemical Identity
of Identical Twins using Mineral Analysis.
Versieck J., Cornelis R.; Trace Elements in Human
Plasma or Serum. CRC Press 1989.
Kaplan A.L. Pesce A.J.; Clinical Chemistry, 2nd ed.
Mosby Co.
Thomas L.; Labor und Diagnose. 4.ed. Med Verlagsges
Marburg, 1982.
Valkovic V.; Human Hair Vol I & II. CRC Press
1988.
|